I'm writing a thesis by publication and I'm not sure how it works
Choose papers that tell one story, handle co-authorship properly and plan the chapters that hold them together.
In short
Start here, today. Find your program's rules for a thesis by publication in the handbook or graduate school regulations. Write down the number of papers required, the publication status each must have, the rules on co-authored work and contribution statements, and what linking material is expected. This takes about 30 minutes.
After that, work through these steps. Choose one to jump to it.
Step by step
Tick each step as you finish it. Open a step for the how.
0 of 6 steps done
Get the rules in writing
Read the handbook, the graduate school's thesis regulations and its formatting guide. If anything is unclear, such as whether a paper under review counts, ask your graduate coordinator by email and keep the reply. Check again a year before you plan to submit, because rules do change.
Plan papers that tell one story
Write one paragraph describing the overarching question of your thesis, then one sentence for each paper saying which part of that question it answers. If a paper doesn't fit, either the paragraph needs widening or the paper belongs outside the thesis. A few connected papers make a stronger thesis than more scattered ones.
Agree authorship early and record your contribution
Talk with your supervisor and co-authors about author order and roles before writing starts, not at submission. Many programs ask for a statement of your contribution to each co-authored paper, sometimes confirmed or signed by co-authors. The CRediT contributor roles give you a shared vocabulary, and notes kept as you go save you reconstructing it years later.
Plan the linking chapters from the start
The introduction sets out the overall problem, the gap and how each paper addresses part of it. Short connecting text explains why each paper follows the last. The final discussion brings the findings together and says what they show as a whole, which no single paper can say. Keep a running file of ideas for each of these while you write the papers.
Handle papers at different stages
Give each paper's status clearly, such as published, under review or in preparation, in the format your program asks for. Before including a published version, check the journal's copyright or licence terms for theses, since conditions vary. If reviewers change a paper after you've drafted the thesis, decide with your supervisor which version the thesis should contain.
Manage overlap and consistency
Each paper has its own literature review and methods, so the thesis can feel repetitive. Find out whether your program lets you edit papers for the thesis. Where it does, let the introduction carry the shared background and cross-reference instead of repeating, and make terms, abbreviations and notation consistent or explain where they differ.
Words you can use
Is this you? Signs to look for
- You have papers planned or written, but you can't explain what they add up to.
- You aren't sure whether papers need to be published, submitted or just drafted to count.
- Co-authors did part of the work and you don't know how to show which parts were yours.
- The introduction and final discussion feel like an afterthought you haven't planned for.
Why this happens
A thesis by publication (also called a manuscript-based, article-based or integrated thesis) is still one thesis. Examiners read the papers as parts of a single contribution, so the work isn't only in the papers; it's also in showing how they connect. Students often discover this late and find the linking chapters take much longer than they expected.
The rules vary a great deal. Universities differ on how many papers you need, whether they must be published or only submitted, how co-authored papers are treated, whether papers written before you enrolled can count, and how published versions may be reproduced. Some departments add their own requirements on top. Advice from a friend at another university may simply not apply to you.
Papers also move at different speeds. At submission, one may be published, one under review and one still a manuscript. That's common, but you need to know how your program wants each one presented.
Worth a look (5)
- CRediT contributor roles taxonomyStandard roles for describing who did what on a co-authored paper.
- Writing for Peer Reviewed Journals, by Pat Thomson and Barbara KamlerPractical help with turning doctoral research into journal articles.
- Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL)Free guides on every part of academic writing, from structuring a paragraph to citing sources. A good first stop when you're unsure how something should look.
- Writing Center Tips & ToolsShort, friendly handouts answer almost any writing question, from literature reviews and abstracts to passive voice and conclusions. Reach for them when one particular thing is tripping you up.
- Writing AdviceShort, practical pages walk you through planning, drafting and revising, with advice on literature reviews, lab reports and using sources. They're easy to dip into when you have one question.
When to bring someone in
Your graduate coordinator or graduate school can clarify the rules; ask in writing and keep the answer. For authorship disagreements, start with your supervisor, and if that doesn't resolve it, talk to your program director or the ombudsperson. A copyright or scholarly communication librarian can tell you what publishers allow you to include in a thesis.
Find the right person, or talk to Ify